Comparison
Starter-Current Testing
Peak Clamp Meter vs Scope Probe
Choose a clamp meter for a DC starter-current peak or a Pico probe and scope for a saved waveform. Compare timing, ranges, jaw access and complete-kit needs.
By thisMETER EditorialUpdated November 3, 20267 min read
On this page · Quick picks: buy the capture method
For a captured starter-current DC peak, our handheld pick is the Hioki CM4373-50, whose manual documents DC PEAK MAX/MIN and a minimum peak width of 1 ms with the filter disabled. For a saved current waveform aligned with battery voltage through cranking, choose a Pico TA167 with a PicoScope 4425A and the complete connection kit below. Buy according to the result you need: a peak value or a time record you can revisit.
Quick picks: buy the capture method
- Handheld peak: Hioki CM4373-50. Choose it for a documented DC peak function without a computer.
- Saved current plus voltage: Pico TA167 + PicoScope 4425A. Choose it when the timing and shape of the event matter.
- Only routine DC readings? Keep that purchase in our DC clamp-meter guide; require explicit DC capture evidence before using any ordinary display reading as a starting-current peak.
Compare specifications and all conditions
Exact hardware
- Hioki handheld route
- CM4373-50 base meter
- Pico waveform route
- TA167 probe + 4425A, PQ174 scope-only package
Current ranges
- Hioki handheld route
- 600.0 A / 2000 A DC
- Pico waveform route
- 200 A / 2000 A AC peak or DC
Capture evidence
- Hioki handheld route
- DC PEAK MAX/MIN; widths ≥1 ms, filter off
- Pico waveform route
- Current and voltage waveforms on the scope’s shared time axis
Maximum conductor diameter
- Hioki handheld route
- 55 mm
- Pico waveform route
- 32 mm
Power to plan for
- Hioki handheld route
- Two supplied LR03 alkaline batteries
- Pico waveform route
- TA167: 9 V alkaline battery; scope: computer USB
What to retain
- Hioki handheld route
- Peak readings; optional app snapshots have limits
- Pico waveform route
- Saved waveform data and vehicle/test details
Full comparison table
Swipe to compare. Row labels stay visible.
| Buying question | Hioki handheld route | Pico waveform route |
|---|---|---|
| Exact hardware | CM4373-50 base meter | TA167 probe + 4425A, PQ174 scope-only package |
| Current ranges | 600.0 A / 2000 A DC | 200 A / 2000 A AC peak or DC |
| Capture evidence | DC PEAK MAX/MIN; widths ≥1 ms, filter off | Current and voltage waveforms on the scope’s shared time axis |
| Maximum conductor diameter | 55 mm | 32 mm |
| Power to plan for | Two supplied LR03 alkaline batteries | TA167: 9 V alkaline battery; scope: computer USB |
| What to retain | Peak readings; optional app snapshots have limits | Saved waveform data and vehicle/test details |
Scroll horizontally to see every column
| Buying question | Hioki handheld route | Pico waveform route |
|---|---|---|
| Exact hardware | CM4373-50 base meter | TA167 probe + 4425A, PQ174 scope-only package |
| Current ranges | 600.0 A / 2000 A DC | 200 A / 2000 A AC peak or DC |
| Capture evidence | DC PEAK MAX/MIN; widths ≥1 ms, filter off | Current and voltage waveforms on the scope’s shared time axis |
| Maximum conductor diameter | 55 mm | 32 mm |
| Power to plan for | Two supplied LR03 alkaline batteries | TA167: 9 V alkaline battery; scope: computer USB |
| What to retain | Peak readings; optional app snapshots have limits | Saved waveform data and vehicle/test details |
Best for a DC peak: Hioki CM4373-50
Hioki’s CM4370-series starter example explicitly describes instantaneous DC current extremes when an engine starts. The CM4373-50 manual then supplies the model-specific evidence: DC PEAK MAX/MIN and a peak-detection time width of 1 ms or more with the filter disabled. That is why this is our peak pick; its generic INRUSH label is not the basis for the recommendation.
Use the right capture function. Hioki separates MAX/MIN/AVG, which follow the displayed measurement interval, from PEAK, which follows waveform extremes after 10 kHz sampling. The ordinary DC-current display updates 5 times/s, so watching it during cranking is not equivalent to arming PEAK. The manual excludes MAX/MIN/AVG/PEAK from Auto AC/DC mode: select the DC-current function, zero the meter and follow the manual’s PEAK procedure before the event.
Read the peak accuracy row. On the 600.0 A range, the DC peak table specifies ±10 A to ±1500 A, 1 A resolution, and ±(1.3% of reading + 7 A). That differs from the 0.1 A step in the ordinary DC table; do not assign the normal display’s finer step or accuracy to the captured peak. The ordinary current ranges are 600.0 A and 2000 A, with a 55 mm maximum conductor diameter. Check physical clearance around the cable as well as its diameter before ordering.
Resolve the US package name. The US product page is headed CM4373-90, but its order table also lists CM4373-50 without Z3210. This pick is the base -50 package: L9300 leads, C0203 case and two LR03 alkaline batteries are listed accessories. The -90 adds the wireless adapter; -93 adds that adapter and the P2010 high-voltage probe. Those extras are not prerequisites for the handheld DC peak route.
The app nuance matters. With Z3210, Hioki offers GENNECT Cross waveform display, including retrieval of two saved inrush waveforms. The app’s Waveform Graph/FFT specifications list one instrument connection and JPEG saving without waveform measured values. We therefore recommend the scope when the deliverable is a reusable current-and-voltage cranking record, rather than assuming these snapshots provide the same workflow.
Best for saved waveforms: Pico TA167 with PicoScope 4425A
The TA167 is a current-to-voltage probe: its 2 m safety-BNC cable connects to the recorder; the probe alone is not this capture system. Its manual confirms 200 A and 2000 A ranges, while the product page specifies 10 mV/A and 1 mV/A switchable sensitivities. Use 10 mV/A for the 200 A range and 1 mV/A for the 2000 A range. Match the software’s probe scaling to the selected hardware range; do not expect the BNC probe to auto-configure like a PicoBNC+ clamp.
The 32 mm conductor opening is smaller than the Hioki’s 55 mm opening. Pico specifies a load of more than 100 kΩ and no more than 100 pF; the 4425A input is 1 MΩ in parallel with 24 pF, and its PicoBNC+ sockets accept existing BNC probes. This documents the electrical load and connector match rather than relying on the connector’s appearance alone.
Do not combine the headline limits. TA167 bandwidth is DC to 20 kHz (−1 dB), subject to I_RMS × f ≤ 400,000. The maximum-current headline is not permission to measure full-scale alternating current throughout that bandwidth. The probe requires a 9 V alkaline battery, zeroing away from the current-carrying conductor, and attention to its automatic power-off setting.
TA167 versus TA388: the TA388 uses PicoBNC+, draws power from the scope, and automatically configures, ranges and zeroes when connected. Consider that alternative for a new 4425A setup if you want those conveniences; keep TA167 when ordinary BNC output is the requirement. The TA388 requires a PicoBNC+ recorder such as 4225A or 4425A; it is a different part, not an included TA167 upgrade.
Check TA167 probe details · Check the 4425A recorder options
Buying guide: order a working recorder setup
This is an assembled shopping list for current plus battery voltage, not the name of a factory bundle. Compare the whole order before choosing the probe.
Recorder
- Exact order or requirement
- PicoScope 4425A, PQ174 scope only
- Why it belongs
- Four input channels; ordinary BNC probes supported
Current probe
- Exact order or requirement
- TA167 plus its specified 9 V alkaline battery, or the TA388 alternative
- Why it belongs
- Probe-only purchases require the recorder
Battery-voltage lead
- Exact order or requirement
- TA125 blue BNC-to-4 mm lead
- Why it belongs
- Separate voltage signal for correlation with current
Battery contacts
- Exact order or requirement
- TA157 red clip + TA158 black clip
- Why it belongs
- Both fit Pico BNC-to-4 mm leads
Computer connection
- Exact order or requirement
- Suitable computer; USB-A-to-B or USB-C-to-B cable listed with the scope
- Why it belongs
- USB supplies the recorder’s power and data connection
Software
- Exact order or requirement
- PicoScope Automotive; Windows for PicoDiagnostics
- Why it belongs
- PicoScope supports Windows, macOS and Linux; PicoDiagnostics is Windows only
Full comparison table
Swipe to compare. Row labels stay visible.
| Component | Exact order or requirement | Why it belongs |
|---|---|---|
| Recorder | PicoScope 4425A, PQ174 scope only | Four input channels; ordinary BNC probes supported |
| Current probe | TA167 plus its specified 9 V alkaline battery, or the TA388 alternative | Probe-only purchases require the recorder |
| Battery-voltage lead | TA125 blue BNC-to-4 mm lead | Separate voltage signal for correlation with current |
| Battery contacts | TA157 red clip + TA158 black clip | Both fit Pico BNC-to-4 mm leads |
| Computer connection | Suitable computer; USB-A-to-B or USB-C-to-B cable listed with the scope | USB supplies the recorder’s power and data connection |
| Software | PicoScope Automotive; Windows for PicoDiagnostics | PicoScope supports Windows, macOS and Linux; PicoDiagnostics is Windows only |
Scroll horizontally to see every column
| Component | Exact order or requirement | Why it belongs |
|---|---|---|
| Recorder | PicoScope 4425A, PQ174 scope only | Four input channels; ordinary BNC probes supported |
| Current probe | TA167 plus its specified 9 V alkaline battery, or the TA388 alternative | Probe-only purchases require the recorder |
| Battery-voltage lead | TA125 blue BNC-to-4 mm lead | Separate voltage signal for correlation with current |
| Battery contacts | TA157 red clip + TA158 black clip | Both fit Pico BNC-to-4 mm leads |
| Computer connection | Suitable computer; USB-A-to-B or USB-C-to-B cable listed with the scope | USB supplies the recorder’s power and data connection |
| Software | PicoScope Automotive; Windows for PicoDiagnostics | PicoScope supports Windows, macOS and Linux; PicoDiagnostics is Windows only |
Package traps: PQ176 is the four-channel Starter Kit with PicoBNC+ test leads and selected adapters; PQ174 is scope only. A “Starter Kit” name is not a promise of a starter-current probe: explicitly include the chosen clamp in the order. The 4225A has two channels, enough for a current-and-voltage pair; the 4425A has four, and Pico reserves its automated battery-to-starter cable voltage-drop/resistance assessment for four-channel scopes. That expansion is our reason to choose the 4425A here.
- Yes: A single DC peak is the deliverable: the Hioki route fits.
- Yes: Current and voltage must be compared in time: the scope route fits.
- Partly: Hioki app waveform snapshots: available with the adapter, with JPEG/data-export limits.
- No: A Pico test-and-measurement scope is not an Automotive-software substitute.
Before ordering, install the intended software release and try demo mode on the intended computer. Pico explicitly excludes its Test & Measurement scopes, including the 2000 Series, from Automotive software support. Use our beginner oscilloscope guide for general bench choices; this purchase needs the documented automotive recorder/software pairing.
Capture a useful record, then interpret it
For the scope route, retain DC coupling to preserve the signal’s DC level; AC coupling removes the offset. Use a timebase covering the event and enough samples to retain its detail; a longer time window without adequate sampling can lose information. A single trigger can capture the first qualifying event, and pre-trigger positioning retains context around its start.
Establish the connections
Follow the maker’s battery-test connection guide and the vehicle’s service procedure; identify the intended current path.
Prepare the probe
Connect the TA167 to the recorder before fitting it around the conductor; zero it away from current.
Set the capture
Match probe scaling and range, preserve the DC level, and choose the trigger and time window for the event.
Review and retain
Check the full event for over-ranging; save waveform data with the vehicle and test details.
Pico illustrates cranking captures with battery voltage and starter current together; that supports examining voltage behaviour at the same moment as current, rather than comparing unrelated extremes. Save the Psdata capture for later waveform work, and include the range and connection context in the test details. Do not turn a current maximum into a diagnosis by itself: Pico’s fuller battery test also uses battery specifications and ambient temperature.
For ordinary lead-based vehicle checks, use our automotive multimeter guide. Keep the routine meter and the event recorder as separate buying decisions.
How we choose
These recommendations compare official product pages, model-specific manuals, capture specifications, connector/load compatibility and documented package options. They are based on manufacturer documentation, not physical testing. We distinguish a current probe from its recorder, ordinary MAX/MIN from DC peak capture, and waveform snapshots from reusable multichannel data. Our selection method explains the research approach; no Amazon listing has been verified for these new records.
Verdict
Choose Hioki CM4373-50 for a documented handheld DC peak, provided its timing, range and jaw suit the job. Choose TA167 + PicoScope 4425A with the voltage lead, clips and computer for saved current-and-voltage waveforms; consider TA388 if you prefer the PicoBNC+ power and configuration conveniences. If neither capture result is needed, stay with a routine DC clamp rather than buying this recorder setup.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best clamp meter for automotive starter-current testing?
Our handheld choice is the Hioki CM4373-50 when the required result is a captured DC peak. Its manual specifies peak detection for widths of 1 ms or more with the filter disabled. Choose the Pico scope route when you need to compare current and battery voltage through the same crank event, rather than keeping only extreme readings.
Does AC inrush mode measure a DC starter-current peak?
An AC inrush label alone does not establish DC peak performance; require the exact manual to document DC operation and capture timing. For this Hioki, the evidence is its separate DC PEAK MAX/MIN specification and the maker’s DC starter example. Ordinary MAX/MIN records the displayed measurement interval, whereas PEAK follows waveform extremes, so the names should not be treated as interchangeable.
Can I use a Pico TA167 without buying an oscilloscope?
The TA167 outputs a voltage over BNC and needs a compatible recording instrument to produce the waveform discussed here. It is not a standalone handheld readout. This guide pairs it with a PicoScope 4425A, voltage lead, battery clips and computer. The TA388 is a different, scope-powered PicoBNC+ option; do not assume its automatic configuration or power arrangement applies to the battery-powered TA167.
How many amps should a starter motor draw?
Use the vehicle’s service information rather than treating either clamp’s maximum range as a pass/fail threshold. Pico’s battery-test workflow requires battery specifications and ambient temperature, and evaluates the starting system under cranking load. For this buying decision, identify whether you need a peak, the cranking waveform or a fuller system assessment before choosing the capture method.
Related guides
Comparison · Clamp Meters
Fluke i410 vs i1010: Which Current Clamp Fits Your Multimeter?
Choose the Fluke i410 or i1010 for your existing multimeter. Compare useful current ranges, voltage inputs, accuracy, jaw clearance and complete kit contents.
Comparison · Clamp Meters
Fluke 368 FC vs Hioki CM4001: Best Clamp for Small AC Leakage?
Choose between Fluke 368 FC and Hioki CM4001 for AC leakage. Compare useful low-current ranges, filters, jaw access and the complete wireless recording setup.
Comparison · Clamp Meters
Klein CL390 vs Fieldpiece SC440: Which HVAC Clamp Meter?
Compare Klein CL390 and Fieldpiece SC440 for heating service: inrush, DC clamp current, flame-sensor microamps, temperature probes and complete kit choices.